
David Shaw, director at Torridon, questions whether design and build contracts always deliver the cost certainty clients expect on refurbishment projects
YOU can pay a premium to transfer risk to a contractor and still end up carrying some of the biggest financial risks yourself, which is something I think clients need to be particularly careful about when using design and build contracts on refurbishment projects. I regularly come across projects where the client appoints a design team, develops the design right through to RIBA Stage 4, and then tenders it on a design and build contract. In effect, the project has been procured traditionally, with a design and build contract bolted on at the end. Contractors sometimes call this ‘design and dump’!
When I see it, I wonder what the client thinks they’re getting. By that stage most of the design is done. The contractor might pick up final detailing and coordination, but the fundamental decisions about the building have already been made.
It’s a bit like buying a flat-pack wardrobe from IKEA, paying someone to assemble it and then assuming they’re responsible if the wardrobe doesn’t fit in your room!
Taking on design responsibility has a cost. Contractors have to weigh the liabilities they’re accepting, and that goes straight into their price. If the client has already paid a professional team to take the design to Stage 4, it’s fair to ask what they gain by paying a contractor to take responsibility for it, especially when the extent of that responsibility can vary enormously from one contract to the next.
There can be good reasons for doing it, but in my experience it’s usually a last ditch attempt to stop coordination issues coming back on the client. A single point of responsibility for finishing and coordinating the design is attractive, particularly where there’s a lot of specialist subcontractor design. This can sometimes be worth paying for, but clients should know how much they’re paying.
What concerns me more on refurbishment projects is the existing building, for example simple issues causing problems, like the slab that turns out to be 150mm rather than the 200mm that was shown on the record drawings, or the services that run nowhere near where the drawings had them noted. Even after reasonable investigations, many of these types of issue only comes to light once work starts on site.
Using a design and build contract doesn’t move that risk to the contractor. Whether it moves at all depends on the contract terms and on what information was issued at tender.
If contractors are asked to carry significant unknowns, they will price them. The client can end up paying for risks that never materialise or, worse, believing they’ve transferred risks they’re still paying for.
Gaps in the Stage 4 information work the same way. A design and build contract doesn’t make them disappear. Unless the employer’s requirements spell out exactly what is left to design and what the contractor can rely on, those gaps tend to resurface during construction as arguments over who pays.
This is why we push clients to challenge the procurement route on refurbishment projects, particularly when we’re appointed early enough to influence it. If the design is substantially complete, is there a genuine benefit to transferring design responsibility at that point? And is it worth what the contractor will charge for it? More often than not, the answer points back to traditional procurement.
I’d also like to see far more investigation of the existing building before contractors are asked to price it. Intrusive surveys and opening-up works cost money, but very little compared with what they can prevent. A week of opening-up might cost tens of thousands. A single unforeseen structural problem found mid-contract can easily run to six figures once redesign and delay are added. You will never find everything, but where an investigation could change the design or the budget, that money is far better spent before tender than after it.
A fixed price is not the same as cost certainty. A contractor can agree a fixed price for a defined scope, based on stated assumptions and an agreed split of risk. The client’s final cost can still move, because any change or unforeseen condition that gives the contractor an entitlement feeds straight into the final account. If the client doesn’t know where those risks sit, the fixed price offers a false sense of security.
So before tendering a Stage 4 design on a design and build contract, consider two questions: What is the contractor actually being paid to take on, and what risk are you still holding? If you can’t answer the second one clearly, the contract hasn’t bought you the certainty you think it has.








