- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
Home Comment Is your construction project in trouble? The warning signs you shouldn’t ignore

Is your construction project in trouble? The warning signs you shouldn’t ignore

Ryan McCuaig, Anderson Strathern
Ryan McCuaig

By Ryan McCuaig, senior associate, construction disputes, Anderson Strathern

WHEN you’re working on a construction project, the last thing you want to hear is that one of the businesses involved has run into financial difficulties. Unfortunately, the risk of this happening on any given project is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.

Construction insolvencies remain above pre-pandemic levels, activity across the sector has slowed and the Building Cost Information Service (BCIS) predicts building costs will rise by 14% over the next five years.

With contractors already operating on tight margins, and the cost of materials, energy and transport continuing to put pressure on businesses, there’s little room for things to go wrong.

To add to the pressure, when one company runs into financial difficulty, the consequences can quickly spread across an entire project. A subcontractor insolvency could leave a main contractor scrambling to find a replacement, delaying work and pushing up costs. For the client commissioning the project, it could mean construction delays and a much bigger bill than expected. The trouble is that financial difficulties aren’t always obvious until it’s too late.

Four warning signs worth watching

There’s no foolproof way to predict whether a contractor or subcontractor is heading for insolvency. But changes in behaviour can sometimes suggest that something isn’t quite right.

1. Communication suddenly drops off. A project partner who’s usually quick to respond becomes difficult to reach, avoids meetings or stops providing regular updates. There could be a perfectly reasonable explanation, but a sudden change in communication is worth following up.

2. Payment disputes become more frequent. Disagreements over payments aren’t unusual in construction – the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 (‘the Construction Act’) provides for a statutory payment regime and right to adjudication to help protect cash flow on construction projects, but if a party starts challenging sums that wouldn’t previously have been disputed, or becomes noticeably more aggressive about payment terms, or threats to adjudicate, it could suggest cash flow is becoming tight.

3. Work starts slipping behind schedule. Delays happen for all sorts of reasons, from bad weather to problems sourcing materials. But repeated delays, or a noticeable drop off in site presence, particularly where there’s no clear explanation, should prompt questions about whether the contractor has the resources to complete the work.

4. Contractual terms become a sticking point. A party might suddenly take a much firmer line on delay, payment, or other contractual obligations. Again, this doesn’t necessarily mean they’re in trouble, but it’s worth understanding what’s driving the change.

None of these signs is a definitive signal that a business is in financial difficulty. But if several start emerging in close succession, it’s sensible to ask questions or to take advice rather than hope the situation resolves itself.

Don’t wait for things to get worse

One of the most important things construction businesses can do is maintain good working relationships across the project – but maintaining those relationships shouldn’t come at the expense of protecting your own business.

If concerns arise, having an open conversation early can help establish what’s happening and whether there’s a way to resolve the problem before it escalates.

It’s important to understand your contractual position, including what rights you have if work is delayed, payments are disputed or a contractor becomes insolvent. Protections such as collateral warranties, parent company guarantees and performance bonds can help limit financial exposure, but businesses need to ensure they have put these into place effectively and understand their rights under these protections.

If a payment dispute does arise, adjudication can provide a relatively quick way of resolving it without going through lengthy court proceedings. The key is to get legal advice early. Withholding payments or terminating a contract without fully understanding your rights could leave you vulnerable to expensive court proceedings and claims for damages.

Size doesn’t always matter

Smaller contractors and subcontractors can be particularly vulnerable to cash flow problems: they often have less financial breathing space, so even one delayed payment can make it difficult to cover wages, materials and other costs. And when they’re waiting to be paid by businesses further up the supply chain, those pressures can quickly build.

However, we have seen in recent years that even the largest contractors are not immune. If a subcontractor goes out of business midway through a project, the main contractor may have to find someone else to complete the work, potentially at a higher cost and with significant delays. This and other rising costs could affect the same contractor across multiple projects.

The consequences can also continue long after construction is complete. If defects emerge and the original contractor is no longer around to put them right, establishing who is responsible and recovering the cost of repairs can become much more complicated.

Once a company becomes insolvent, administrators or liquidators may take control of its affairs, leaving those owed money or facing unfinished work in a difficult position. By that stage, the options available to recover losses or keep a project moving may be much more limited.

Looking ahead

With the draft Scottish budget coming out in December, there’s an opportunity for the Scottish Government to recognise the pressures facing the industry and consider what more can be done to support construction businesses. With rising costs, tighter margins and the industry facing a new tax in the form of the Building Safety Levy, greater support for the sector would be welcome.

There’s only so much any company can do about rising costs or the financial position of project partners. But keeping an eye out for warning signs, maintaining good relationships, taking advice early, and understanding the options available can make a real difference.